Victor Wembanyama is no longer a prospect. He’s a legitimate MVP candidate in his second season, and his card market reflects it.
But here’s the interesting part: despite his on-court dominance, his card prices have actually stabilized compared to his rookie year peaks. Let’s break down where Wemby cards stand in February 2026 and where they’re headed.
The Current State of Wemby Cards
Flagship Rookies (2023-24 Season)
2023 Prizm Silver
- Raw: $200-$280 (down from $350 peak in April 2024)
- PSA 10: $700-$850 (down from $1,100 peak)
- PSA 9: $280-$360
2023 Select Courtside Tri-Color /149
- Raw: $280-$380 (down from $500 peak)
- PSA 10: $650-$800
2023 Mosaic Silver
- Raw: $90-$140
- PSA 10: $300-$420
2023 Donruss Optic Holo
- Raw: $80-$120
- PSA 10: $250-$350
Why Did Prices Drop from Rookie Year?
1. Market Correction After Hype Peak
Wemby’s rookie cards peaked in April-May 2024 during his Rookie of the Year run and Spurs’ playoff push. Prices were driven by FOMO, not fundamentals.
Summer 2024 saw a 30-40% correction as the hype settled and collectors realized his rookie cards were overpriced relative to comps.
2. Second-Year Supply Entered the Market
2024-25 Prizm/Select releases gave collectors a “cheaper” Wemby option. While technically not rookies, many casual collectors bought 2024-25 base cards instead of paying premiums for 2023-24 rookies.
This diverted demand and put downward pressure on rookie year cards.
3. Cooper Flagg Narrative Steal
The 2025 draft brought Cooper Flagg to San Antonio. Suddenly, Flagg was the hot rookie story, and Wemby became “the veteran star helping the rookie.” This shifted collecting attention and dollars.
4. General Hobby Cooling
The broader card market has cooled in late 2025 / early 2026. Prices across the board are down 10-20% from 2024 peaks as the post-COVID boom fully normalizes.
But Wait — Wemby Is BETTER This Year
Here’s the paradox: Wemby’s on-court performance in 2025-26 is better than his rookie year.
2023-24 Stats: 21.4 PPG, 10.6 RPG, 3.9 BPG 2025-26 Stats (through Feb): 24.8 PPG, 11.2 RPG, 4.2 APG, 4.1 BPG, 38% from 3PT
He’s a legitimate MVP candidate. The Spurs are the #3 seed in the West. He’s playing alongside Cooper Flagg and forming one of the league’s most exciting young duos.
So why aren’t his cards rising?
The Disconnect: Performance vs. Card Prices
On-Court Value ≠ Card Value
Card prices are driven by:
- Scarcity (rookie cards > any other year)
- Narrative (rookie year hype > established star consistency)
- Speculation (potential > proven commodity)
Wemby’s rookie cards are scarce and will always command premiums. But his ceiling is now known. He’s not “the next” anything — he’s already arrived.
Established Stars Plateau Faster
Once a player proves they’re elite, card prices stabilize. Look at Luka Dončić: his rookie Prizm Silver peaked at ~$1,500 PSA 10 in 2021, then settled around $600-$800 despite him being a perennial MVP candidate.
Wemby is following the same trajectory: peak during the hype phase, plateau during the “oh yeah, he’s just really good” phase.
Where Wemby Cards Are Headed
Short-Term (March-June 2026): Upside Likely
If the Spurs make a deep playoff run (Finals appearance), Wemby cards will spike 20-30%. Playoff exposure drives casual buyer interest.
If he wins MVP (currently +800 odds, trailing Jokić and SGA), expect another 15-20% bump.
Prediction: Prizm Silver PSA 10 hits $900-$1,000 if Spurs reach the Finals.
Medium-Term (1-2 Years): Stability
Barring injury, Wemby is a lock for multiple All-NBA selections and likely wins an MVP in the next 3 years. His cards will hold value but not explode unless he wins a championship.
Prediction: Prizm Silver PSA 10 trades in the $700-$900 range with seasonal fluctuations.
Long-Term (5-10 Years): Generational Asset
If Wemby wins multiple championships and MVPs (and stays healthy), his rookie Prizm Silver becomes a generational blue-chip card in the $1,500-$2,500 range.
If he suffers major injuries or stalls development, prices decline to $400-$600.
Most Likely Outcome: He wins 1-2 championships, multiple MVPs, and his Prizm Silver settles as a $1,200-$1,800 PSA 10 card long-term. Think Giannis Antetokounmpo or Tim Duncan tier.
Best Wemby Cards to Buy Right Now
For Investors
2023 Prizm Silver PSA 10 — The benchmark. Buy under $750 if available.
2023 Select Courtside Tri-Color /149 — Underpriced beauty. Buy raw under $300 or PSA 10 under $700.
2023 Bowman Chrome Auto /99 — Long-term hold, current price $1,200-$1,800.
For Collectors (Best Value)
2023 Mosaic Silver PSA 10 — $300-$400 gets you a graded Wemby rookie. Great for PCs.
2023 Donruss Optic Holo — Budget option at $80-$120 raw.
2024-25 Prizm Silver — Not a rookie, but $60-$90 gets you a beautiful card of an MVP candidate.
For Gamblers
2023 Prizm Mojo /25 — $2,500-$4,000 right now. If he wins MVP, this hits $6,000+.
2023 Prizm Gold /10 — $8,000-$12,000 range. Championship run doubles it.
Cards to Avoid
❌ 2023 Hoops Base — Cheap cardboard, minimal upside ❌ 2023 Donruss Base — No NBA logos, no premium ❌ 2024-25 base cards — Not rookies, casual collectors don’t care ❌ Graded 8s and below — Even for Wemby, condition matters
The Flagg Effect: Threat or Opportunity?
Cooper Flagg joining the Spurs creates an interesting dynamic:
Potential Threat
- Flagg steals Wemby’s “hot young Spur” narrative
- Collector dollars shift to Flagg’s cheaper rookie cards
- Wemby becomes “the other guy” in media coverage
Potential Opportunity
- Spurs become must-watch TV, raising all Spurs card values
- Wemby-Flagg duo wins championships, elevating both
- “Twin Towers 2.0” narrative creates historical collecting angle
Our Take: It’s an opportunity. Great teams create rising tides. If Spurs win titles with Wemby + Flagg, both become blue-chip long-term holds.
Comp to Other Generational Talents
Let’s compare Wemby’s trajectory to other recent generational rookies:
Luka Dončić (2018 Rookie)
- Peak Prizm Silver PSA 10: $1,500 (2021)
- Current: $600-$800
- Trajectory: Spike, then plateau despite elite performance
Zion Williamson (2019 Rookie)
- Peak Prizm Silver PSA 10: $1,000 (2020)
- Current: $150-$250
- Trajectory: Injury concerns killed long-term value
Ja Morant (2019 Rookie)
- Peak Prizm Silver PSA 10: $700 (2022)
- Current: $200-$300
- Trajectory: Off-court issues and injury concerns tanked prices
Wemby’s Path: Most similar to Luka. Elite play, good team, consistent production. Expect similar price stability with upside during championship runs.
Should You Buy Wemby Cards in February 2026?
YES, if:
✅ You believe Spurs make the Finals this year (playoff spike) ✅ You’re building a long-term PC of generational talents ✅ You can buy Prizm Silver PSA 10 under $750 (good entry point) ✅ You want a “safe” modern card investment with upside
NO, if:
❌ You’re chasing quick flips (market has stabilized) ❌ You think his ceiling is already priced in (it probably is) ❌ You’d rather speculate on cheaper rookies (Flagg, Harper, Bailey offer more upside %)
The Bottom Line
Wemby cards are in a healthy place. The hype has cooled, the performance is elite, and prices reflect a generational talent without the irrational FOMO of 2024.
Current Prices:
- 2023 Prizm Silver PSA 10: $700-$850 ✅ Fair value
- 2023 Select Courtside /149 raw: $280-$380 ✅ Undervalued
- 2023 Mosaic Silver PSA 10: $300-$420 ✅ Budget entry
Outlook:
- Short-term: Playoff run = 20-30% upside
- Medium-term: Stable $700-$900 range
- Long-term: Championship(s) push Prizm Silver to $1,500+
If you missed the 2024 peak, this is your second chance to buy at rational prices. If you bought the peak, hold through the Spurs’ championship window.
Wemby isn’t hype anymore. He’s the real deal. His cards will reflect that over the next decade.
For more on the broader market, check our Sports Card Market Report: February 2026.